KERMO

DVSA MOT data · 2024 to 2025 · normal MOT tests in Great Britain

BMW 5 Series MOT Failure Rate & Common Faults

11% of 5 Series cars failed their MOT in 2024 to 2025, which is 7 percentage points below the national average of 19%. Below you can see what fails most, and how the picture changes with the year each car was first registered.

Key figures for the BMW 5 Series

Fail rate

11%

Pass rate

89%

Tests analysed

294,000

National fail rate

19%

Most common MOT failure reasons for the 5 Series

Each reason is shown as a share of all 5 Series tests in the period, so the percentages add up to more than the fail rate when a car fails for several things at once. Wear and upkeep items are left out of this list: tyres, brake pads and discs, wiper blades, headlamp aim and washer fluid depend on upkeep and driving, so they say little about the model.

  1. Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil spring

    Fractured or broken

    Major

    2%of tests

  2. Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment > Position lamps > Position lamp

    Not working

    Major

    1%of tests

  3. Suspension > Shock absorbers

    Has a serious fluid leak

    Major

    1%of tests

  4. Steering > Steering linkage components > Track rod end

    Ball joint has excessive play

    Major

    1%of tests

  5. Suspension > Suspension arms > Ball joint

    Ball joint excessively worn

    Major

    1%of tests

BMW 5 Series MOT failure rate by year of first registration

Cars first registered in 2021 have the lowest fail rate in this data (2%), and those first registered in 2003 the highest (30%). Years with fewer than 500 tests are left out.

BMW 5 Series tests, fail rate and top failure reason by year of first registration
First registeredTestsFail rateTop reason
200167327%Suspension > Anti-roll bars > Linkage ball joint dust coverBall joint dust cover no longer prevents the ingress of dirt
200288828%Brakes > Brake performance > Parking brake efficiency (sp) > Rbt (sp)Efficiency below requirements
20031,04230%Brakes > Brake performance > Parking brake efficiency (sp) > Rbt (sp)Efficiency below requirements
200490825%Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems > SRS malfunction indicator lampWarning lamp indicates a fault
20051,62027%Suspension > Suspension arms > Pins and bushesPin or bush excessively worn
20064,90727%Steering > Steering linkage components > Track rod endBall joint has excessive play
20077,07725%Steering > Steering linkage components > Track rod endBall joint has excessive play
20086,40921%Suspension > Anti-roll bars > Linkage ball joint dust coverBall joint dust cover no longer prevents the ingress of dirt
20098,67021%Suspension > Anti-roll bars > Linkage ball joint dust coverBall joint dust cover no longer prevents the ingress of dirt
20108,98719%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201116,48719%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201223,89118%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201324,66915%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201423,46311%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201524,5748%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201624,1466%Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil springFractured or broken
201729,3318%Suspension > Shock absorbersHas a serious fluid leak
201837,7866%Suspension > Shock absorbersHas a serious fluid leak
201930,9715%Road Wheels > ConditionFractured
20208,4334%Road Wheels > ConditionFractured
20213,6932%Road Wheels > ConditionFractured
20222,5922%Road Wheels > ConditionFractured

What to check before you buy a 5 Series

The areas that fail most often on a 5 Series are suspension, lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment and steering. Ask the seller for the MOT certificates and look at those parts first, on a test drive and on a lift if you can.

Run the registration through our free MOT history check to see past advisories and failures for that specific car. A pattern of the same advisory over several tests tells you more than any model average.

BMW 5 Series MOT: quick answers

What percentage of 5 Series cars fail their MOT?

11% of 294,000 MOT tests (not retests) on the BMW 5 Series failed in 2024 to 2025, according to DVSA data. That is 7 percentage points below the national average of 19%.

What is the most common MOT failure on a BMW 5 Series?

The most common reason is "Suspension > Springs > Coil springs > Coil spring: Fractured or broken", found in 2% of tests.

Is a BMW 5 Series reliable?

An MOT fail rate is not the same as a breakdown rate. It counts cars that had at least one defect stopping them passing the test. Use it as one signal next to the car's service history and MOT history, and check the areas listed on this page before you buy.

How to read this data

A fail is not a breakdown. An MOT failure means the car had at least one defect that stops it passing the test, such as worn tyres or a faulty lamp. Many failed cars are still driven safely once the job is fixed, and plenty of cars that pass still break down. This page shows what fails the test, not how reliable the car is on the road.

What is counted. Normal MOT tests (not retests) on cars and light vans in Great Britain, from the DVSA anonymised MOT dataset for 2024 and 2025. A car is tested every year, so one car can appear in several years, and the figures count tests rather than individual cars. A test with a pass after work at the test station (PRS) counts as a pass. Years are the year the car was first registered, so an older car is not automatically a worse one.

Severity. “Dangerous” defects are the most serious category in the MOT manual. “Major” defects mean the car fails but is not an immediate danger. The dangerous share next to each reason shows how often that defect was marked dangerous.

Wear and upkeep items. Tyre defects (tread depth, cuts, bulges), brake pads and discs worn below the limit, wiper blades, headlamp aim and washer fluid are not listed as reasons. A test that failed only for these counts as a pass here, because they depend on upkeep and on how the car is driven. For this model, 15,557 tests failed only for these items and were counted this way.

Limits. The dataset is anonymised, so no individual car is shown. Model names are grouped from DVSA's free-text entries, and some variants and trims are merged, so a single model can cover several versions. Northern Ireland tests are not included.

More BMW MOT failure rates

Compare the 5 Series with other BMW models, or browse MOT failure rates for every model.